Understanding the Transgender Revolution
The transgender movement is transforming the way we think about identity, and its impact is being felt across the globe. At its core, this revolution is driven by three key beliefs that have become deeply ingrained in our culture.
From Fixed to Fluid: The Changing Nature of Identity
In the past, identity was seen as something fixed and stable, determined by factors such as family, nationality, and biological sex. However, in recent years, there has been a seismic shift towards a more fluid understanding of identity. Today, identity is seen as a personal project, something that can be created and curated through self-discovery and self-expression.
This shift has been driven in part by the growing recognition of the importance of personal feelings and experiences. However, it also raises important questions about the nature of reality and how we understand ourselves and others. As Carl Trueman notes, “I think I’m a woman, therefore I am a woman” is a peculiarly Cartesian notion that dispenses with the idea of any authority beyond personal conviction.
The Rise of Feeling-Based Identity
One of the key drivers of the transgender movement is the idea that feelings, rather than biology, determine identity. This is reflected in the way that many people now talk about their experiences of gender dysphoria. For example, when asked if he felt like a man, one individual responded, “What does that mean? And don’t tell me it means you like girls and sports. What does it mean to feel like a man?”
This emphasis on feeling-based identity has significant implications for how we understand and care for individuals who experience gender dysphoria. It also raises important questions about the role of biology and the natural world in shaping our understanding of identity.
From Inner Healing to Outer Transformation
The transgender movement is also driven by a desire for transformation and change. However, this desire is often focused on external changes, such as hormone treatments and surgeries, rather than inner healing and transformation. This approach assumes that the deep change that individuals need can be achieved through external means, rather than through a process of inner transformation and growth.
This approach has significant implications for how we understand and care for individuals who experience gender dysphoria. It also raises important questions about the nature of reality and how we understand ourselves and others.
Concerns About Affirmative Therapy
While the transgender movement has brought attention to the importance of caring for individuals who experience gender dysphoria, there are also concerns about the approach of affirmative therapy. This approach often involves encouraging individuals to transition, without fully exploring the underlying issues that may be contributing to their experiences of dysphoria.
There are also concerns about the impact of affirmative therapy on children and adolescents, who may be more vulnerable to social pressure and influence. As one study noted, “socially transitioning a child dramatically increases the likelihood that gender dysphoria will persist.”
A Different Approach
In contrast to the approach of affirmative therapy, some researchers and clinicians are advocating for a more cautious and nuanced approach to caring for individuals who experience gender dysphoria. This approach involves taking a more thorough and comprehensive assessment of an individual’s experiences and needs, and providing care that is tailored to their unique circumstances.
It also involves recognizing the importance of biology and the natural world in shaping our understanding of identity, and avoiding approaches that seek to suppress or deny these realities. As one theologian noted, “nature tends to strike back, with the likely victims in this case being vulnerable and impressionable youngsters who, as confused adults, will pay the price for their elders’ fashionable fantasies.”
Leave a Reply