The Dangers of False Dichotomies in Preaching
As preachers, we often find ourselves caught between two seemingly opposing ideas. But what if these dichotomies are actually false? What if they are cleverly crafted by the enemy to lead us astray and water down our message?
The Exegetical Lecturer vs. The Church Motivator
On one hand, we have the exegetical lecturer who is so focused on presenting the pure Word of God that they neglect to speak to the hearts of their listeners. On the other hand, we have the church motivator who is more concerned with convincing people to adopt certain courses of action than with presenting a clear and balanced message. But what if we could combine the best of both worlds? What if our expositions of Scripture could be fueled by a passion for holy affection and action?
The Spiritual Director vs. The Doctrinal Teacher
Some preachers focus on doling out practical advice and wise counsel, while others emphasize the importance of understanding the system of Christian faith. But why must it be an either-or proposition? Why can’t we strive to have our eyes on Christ as revealed in doctrine, while also keeping our feet firmly planted on the ground to apply that doctrine to the needs of our listeners?
The Verse-by-Verse Expositor vs. The Textual Preacher
Is the only way to expound Scripture to preach through a book of the Bible one verse at a time? Or is it possible to choose specific texts that address the needs of our congregation, while still being faithful to the whole counsel of God? Perhaps the answer lies in finding a balance between the two approaches.
The Storyteller vs. The Pulpit Orator
Some preachers connect with their listeners through narrative and storytelling, while others rely on clear statements of doctrinal truth. But what if we could find a way to combine the two? What if our storytelling could be infused with substantial content, logical clarity, and practical application?
The Piercing Convincer vs. The Positive Attractor
Should we focus on pressing upon the conscience of our listeners, or on attracting them with a message of hope and joy? Perhaps the answer lies in finding a balance between the two. Perhaps our preaching should aim to move people to sorrow for their sins, while also leading them to joyful deliverance through faith in Christ.
Avoiding the Dangers of False Dichotomies
As we consider these five dichotomies, let us beware of letting the enemy drive us from one extreme to another. Let us not believe that these are absolute dichotomies, but rather seek to find a balance between the two. Let us strive to create sermons that are faithful to Scripture and relevant to our listeners; rich in doctrine and rife with practical application; drawn from every part of Scripture, and true to the whole of Scripture. Only then can we truly say that our preaching is “logic on fire” – clear and passionate communication of the truth of God.
Leave a Reply